The IB Philosophy IA is a philosophical analysis of a non-philosophical stimulus, up to 2,000 words. You start with something from everyday life, such as a film scene, a news story, a photograph or an advertisement, find the philosophical issue it raises, and analyse that issue. It is the same task at SL and HL.
The skill being tested is the move from an ordinary situation to a philosophical question, and then doing real philosophy with it.
Choosing a stimulus
A good stimulus is not a philosophy text. A passage from Kant or Sartre is philosophical material, not a stimulus. Look for something that raises a question without answering it.
Stimuli that work well:
- A news story, such as a court case about who is responsible when a self-driving car crashes.
- A film or TV scene, such as a character choosing to lie to protect someone.
- An advertisement, such as one that promises a product will make you "your true self".
- A photograph or artwork, such as a famous staged news photo.
- A product or technology, such as an app that predicts your mood from your typing.
Choose a stimulus you can describe precisely. Vague stimuli lead to vague analysis. Follow your teacher's instructions on including the stimulus or a reference to it with your IA.
Finding the philosophical issue
Ask what the stimulus makes you wonder about. Then turn it into a philosophical question.
| Stimulus | Everyday question | Philosophical issue |
|---|---|---|
| A self-driving car crash case | Who is to blame? | Can a person be morally responsible for an action taken by a machine they own? |
| A character lying to protect a friend | Was the lie OK? | Is lying ever morally required? |
| An advert about "your true self" | Can a product change who I am? | What, if anything, makes a person the same self over time? |
| A mood-predicting app | Is this creepy? | Can behaviour reveal another person's mental states? |
Explain clearly how the stimulus raises the issue. This link is the foundation of the IA.
Structuring 2,000 words
A structure that works for many IAs:
- Introduction (about 250 words): describe the stimulus, identify the philosophical issue, and say how you will approach it.
- Analysis (about 1,200 words): set out two or three positions on the issue, using relevant philosophical concepts and arguments, and apply them back to the stimulus.
- Evaluation (about 400 words): weigh the positions, consider the strongest counterarguments, and explain which view holds up best and why.
- Conclusion (about 150 words): your answer, its limits, and what follows from it.
Doing real analysis
- Use philosophical concepts precisely. If you use "free will", "personal identity" or "utilitarianism", define what you mean.
- Present arguments, not names. "Kant argues..." is less useful than setting out the steps of the argument and testing them.
- Keep returning to the stimulus. Use its details to test the positions you discuss.
- Consider counterarguments seriously. The strongest IAs present the best version of the opposing view before responding.
Building an evaluation
Evaluation is more than "on the other hand". It means judging. Useful questions:
- Which position explains the stimulus best?
- Which assumptions does each position depend on, and are they reasonable?
- Does a position lead to conclusions its defenders would reject?
- Is there a middle position that keeps the strengths of both?
Then state your view and defend it.
Common mistakes
- A philosophical text as the stimulus.
- Describing the stimulus at length instead of analysing the issue.
- Listing philosophers without analysing their arguments.
- No clear position in the evaluation.
- Losing the stimulus after the introduction.