The first section of the IB History IA asks you to pick two sources that matter for your question and evaluate them. Most students know the letters OPVL: origin, purpose, value, limitation. Fewer students know what turns OPVL from a checklist into analysis. The answer is one rule: every value and every limitation should come from the origin, purpose or content of the source, and should be judged against your research question.
This guide covers the current History IA, which is 2,200 words and marked out of 25. The source section is Criterion A (6 marks). A new History guide is planned for first exams in 2028, so if you are in that cohort, check the section names your teacher gives you.
What the source section has to do
In roughly 500 words, Section 1 should:
- State your research question.
- Identify two sources and explain why each one is relevant to that question.
- Analyse each source's origin, purpose and content.
- Use that analysis to judge each source's value and limitations for your investigation.
The last point matters most. A source is not "valuable" in general. It is valuable for answering a particular question. A speech can be weak evidence of what happened and strong evidence of how a government wanted it remembered.
Choosing your two sources
Pick sources you will actually use in the investigation. Examiners notice when the two "evaluated" sources disappear after Section 1.
Good pairs usually do different jobs:
- A primary and a secondary source. For example, a government document and a historian's interpretation of it.
- Two perspectives on the same event. For example, a newspaper from each side of a conflict.
- A source and a later reassessment. For example, a memoir and an archive-based study that challenges it.
Avoid general textbooks and encyclopedia entries. They are fine for background, but there is little to say about their origin and purpose.
Origin: more than a citation
Origin is not just "who wrote it and when". Pick out the parts of the origin that affect how far you can trust the source:
- Author and position. Were they an insider, a witness, an opponent, a historian writing decades later?
- Date and context. Was it written during the event, straight after, or once the outcome was known?
- Type of source. A private diary, a public speech, a court record and an academic monograph each have different strengths.
- Publication and audience. Who was meant to read it, and who published it?
Purpose: why the source exists
Ask what the author wanted the source to do. Inform? Persuade? Justify a decision? Rebuild a reputation? Purpose explains what a source includes, what it leaves out and how it frames events.
For secondary sources, purpose can be the historian's argument. A revisionist study exists to challenge an earlier view. That is useful to you, but it also shapes which evidence the author stresses.
Content: what the source actually says
The IA asks you to consider content, not just origin and purpose. Refer briefly to what the source says or shows, especially where the content supports or complicates your reading of the purpose. Do not summarise it. One or two precise details are enough.
Value and limitation: tie them back
This is where most marks are won or lost. Compare these two sentences about a memoir:
- Weak: "The source is valuable because it is a primary source written by someone who was there."
- Stronger: "Because the author sat on the committee that made the decision, the memoir is valuable for showing which options were discussed. Because it was published after the policy failed, it is limited as evidence of his own role, which he has reason to minimise."
The stronger version names the feature of the source (origin or purpose), explains its effect, and says what that means for the question.
A worked example
Research question: To what extent was Khrushchev's 1956 "Secret Speech" an attempt to protect the Communist Party's authority rather than a full reckoning with Stalinism?
Source: Nikita Khrushchev, "On the Cult of Personality and Its Consequences", speech to a closed session of the 20th Party Congress, February 1956.
- Origin. Delivered by the First Secretary of the party to party delegates, not to the public. Khrushchev had served under Stalin, including in senior posts during the purges.
- Purpose. To condemn Stalin's "cult of personality" and selected abuses, while presenting the party and its current leaders as victims or opponents of those abuses.
- Content. The speech focuses on crimes against party members and military leaders. It says much less about collectivisation and the famine.
- Value. Because it comes from the top of the party, it is strong evidence of how the post-Stalin leadership wanted to explain the past to its own members. That is exactly what the question asks about.
- Limitation. Because Khrushchev had been part of Stalin's system, the speech has reasons to leave out his own role and to narrow the blame to Stalin and a few associates. It is weak evidence of the full extent of repression, so the investigation needs other sources for that.
Notice that the value and the limitation both come from the same origin and purpose. That link is what examiners reward.
Common mistakes
- "Biased, so limited." Every source has a perspective. Say what the perspective is and how it affects this question.
- "Primary, so valuable." Being primary is not a value on its own. Say what it lets you see.
- Translation as a limitation by default. Only mention it if you have a real reason to think it changes the meaning.
- Summarising the content instead of analysing it.
- Running over the word budget. About 500 words is a sensible share. The investigation section carries 15 marks and needs the space.
- Sources that vanish. Use both sources in Section 2.
Before you submit Section 1
- Your research question appears at the start.
- You explain why each source is relevant to the question.
- Each value and limitation names a specific feature of the origin, purpose or content.
- Each judgement is tied to your research question, not to history in general.
- Both sources are used in the investigation.