For each exam session the IB publishes six prescribed titles, and you write your TOK essay on one of them, word for word. The essay is up to 1,600 words and is marked as a whole out of 10. That last point changes how you should work: there is no separate mark for examples or structure. The examiner asks one question: how well does this essay answer this title?
So the most important hour you spend on TOK is the hour before you write, when you work out what the title is really asking. This guide walks through that process.
Step 1: Read the title more slowly than feels necessary
Write the title out and mark every word that carries weight. Prescribed titles are short, and almost every word narrows what you can say.
Look for:
- Key concepts, such as "knowledge", "evidence", "certainty", "interpretation" or "expert".
- Qualifiers, such as "always", "only", "necessarily", "to what extent" or "more".
- Instructions, such as "with reference to two areas of knowledge" or "discuss with reference to history and one other area of knowledge".
If a title names areas of knowledge, you must use those. If it does not, you choose, and the choice needs to suit the question.
To practise below, we will use a title we wrote for this article, in the style of a prescribed title:
"Is agreement among experts a reliable indicator of knowledge? Discuss with reference to two areas of knowledge."
Step 2: Define the key terms for your essay
Do not copy dictionary definitions. Decide what the terms mean for your argument and say so briefly.
In the practice title, "expert" needs care. Is an expert someone with credentials, with experience or with a track record? "Reliable indicator" is also doing work: it does not ask whether agreement is knowledge, only whether it is good evidence of knowledge.
Step 3: Find the assumptions inside the title
Most titles carry an assumption you can question. Here:
- That experts in different fields agree in the same way.
- That agreement is something we can observe and measure.
- That disagreement is a sign of weaker knowledge.
Questioning an assumption is often where the most original part of an essay comes from.
Step 4: Choose your areas of knowledge
Choose two areas of knowledge where the title plays out differently. That contrast gives the essay depth. For the practice title:
- Natural sciences. Scientific consensus is built through peer review and replication. Agreement can be strong evidence, but consensus has also been wrong and revised.
- The arts. Critics often disagree about value, yet that disagreement does not make knowledge in the arts worthless. It may show that the arts aim at something other than a single right answer.
Use the knowledge framework to compare them: the scope of each area, the methods and tools it uses, the perspectives involved and the ethical issues it raises.
Step 5: Build claims and counterclaims
For each area of knowledge, write a claim, a counterclaim and a judgement between them.
- Claim: In the natural sciences, broad expert agreement usually reflects repeated testing, so it is a reliable indicator.
- Counterclaim: Consensus can lag behind evidence. When Barry Marshall and Robin Warren argued in the early 1980s that bacteria cause most stomach ulcers, many specialists rejected the idea; it later won the 2005 Nobel Prize.
- Judgement: Agreement is reliable when it comes from open testing, and less reliable when it rests on authority or habit.
Step 6: Use real, specific examples
The strongest examples are specific and, ideally, not the first ones everyone reaches for. A named study, an event, a court case or a case from your own subjects works better than "for example, a scientist might...".
Explain each example. An example only earns credit when you show how it supports or challenges your claim about knowledge.
Step 7: Plan your 1,600 words
A plan that works for many titles:
- Introduction (about 150 words): your reading of the title, key terms and a clear thesis.
- First area of knowledge (about 600 words): claim, example, counterclaim, judgement.
- Second area of knowledge (about 600 words): the same, with a contrast to the first.
- Conclusion (about 250 words): your answer, its limits and why it matters.
Common mistakes
- Answering a nearby question instead of the one set.
- Describing areas of knowledge instead of using them to argue.
- Hypothetical examples where a real one would be stronger.
- Old course language. "Ways of knowing" were removed from TOK in the course first examined in 2022. Use the current knowledge framework instead.
- A conclusion that only summarises. Give your answer and its implications.