All History guides

History EE Criteria Guide

Use a focused question, strong context, and disciplined evidence to build a defensible line of argument.

For assessment in 2027. Submit a single RPF reflective statement of up to 500 words. This guide follows the EE criteria for history: focus and method, knowledge and understanding, and critical thinking. It keeps the essay narrow enough to support real historical analysis rather than broad narrative.

Assessment criteria

What each criterion measures, how many marks it carries, and what stronger evidence usually looks like.

Criterion names, marks and mark bands follow the IB subject guide. The band descriptions are our own summaries, so check your subject guide for the exact wording.

Criterion A: Framework for the essay (6 marks)

Use a clear question, suitable research methods and an effective essay structure.

Stronger evidence
A precise, relevant question is supported by well-chosen methods and a structure that makes the research easy to follow.
Early-stage evidence
The question lacks focus or relevance, the methods fit poorly, and the structure does little to help the reader.

Criterion B: Knowledge and understanding (6 marks)

Show subject knowledge through relevant sources, concepts and accurate terminology.

Stronger evidence
A well-chosen body of sources supports strong knowledge, with accurate terminology and effective use of relevant concepts.
Early-stage evidence
The chosen material is weakly relevant, concepts receive shallow treatment, and terminology is sparse or inaccurate.

Criterion C: Analysis and line of argument (6 marks)

Analyse the research and connect the question, findings and conclusions.

Stronger evidence
Effective analysis produces relevant findings, and a sustained argument connects these findings to the question and conclusions.
Early-stage evidence
The essay mainly describes its material and the argument is incomplete.

Criterion D: Discussion and evaluation (8 marks)

Weigh the findings and assess the strengths and limits of the research.

Stronger evidence
A balanced discussion is supported throughout. Relevant strengths and limits are explained when judging the research.
Early-stage evidence
The importance of the findings is described without supporting evidence. Evaluation is incomplete and does not identify strengths or limits.

Criterion E: Reflection (4 marks)

Evaluate what the essay taught you and how that learning transfers to other situations.

Stronger evidence
The reflection evaluates the experience throughout, using examples that consistently show growth and transfer.
Early-stage evidence
The reflection recounts the process without showing how learning could transfer.

Mark bands

MarksWhat the draft shows
0Nothing in the work reaches the lowest band.
1-2The question lacks focus or relevance, the methods fit poorly, and the structure does little to help the reader.
3-4The question is partly focused. Mostly suitable methods and the essay's structure support some of the research.
5-6A precise, relevant question is supported by well-chosen methods and a structure that makes the research easy to follow.

MarksWhat the draft shows
0Nothing in the work reaches the lowest band.
1-2The chosen material is weakly relevant, concepts receive shallow treatment, and terminology is sparse or inaccurate.
3-4Relevant sources support some knowledge. Concepts are partly understood and terminology is sometimes accurate.
5-6A well-chosen body of sources supports strong knowledge, with accurate terminology and effective use of relevant concepts.

MarksWhat the draft shows
0Nothing in the work reaches the lowest band.
1-2The essay mainly describes its material and the argument is incomplete.
3-4Some useful analysis produces relevant findings, but the argument has gaps or inconsistencies.
5-6Effective analysis produces relevant findings, and a sustained argument connects these findings to the question and conclusions.

MarksWhat the draft shows
0Nothing in the work reaches the lowest band.
1-2The importance of the findings is described without supporting evidence. Evaluation is incomplete and does not identify strengths or limits.
3-4The discussion has some balance and occasional evidence. Evaluation identifies some strengths and limits.
5-6A balanced discussion often uses evidence. Relevant strengths and limits are described when judging the research.
7-8A balanced discussion is supported throughout. Relevant strengths and limits are explained when judging the research.

MarksWhat the draft shows
0Nothing in the work reaches the lowest band.
1The reflection recounts the process without showing how learning could transfer.
2The reflection includes particular examples, with occasional signs of growth and transfer.
3The reflection weighs parts of the experience, often showing growth and how learning transfers.
4The reflection evaluates the experience throughout, using examples that consistently show growth and transfer.

Want to know where your EE sits in these bands? Upload your draft and get a mark for each criterion.

Grade my EE

How to build it

Most weak drafts fail on order, not on ideas.

  1. 1

    Stress-test the question

    Check that the question is historical, focused, and answerable with the evidence you can realistically access.

  2. 2

    Gather contrasting evidence

    Use sources that support more than one perspective so the argument can move beyond summary.

  3. 3

    Draft analytically

    Let each section make a claim, support it with evidence, and connect it back to the question.

  4. 4

    Revise for consistency

    Make sure the conclusion follows the argument you actually built, not just the topic you chose.

Before you submit

  • The question is precise and clearly historical.
  • Evidence from a range of sources is integrated, not dropped in.
  • Different perspectives are weighed where they matter.
  • The conclusion follows the argument, not just the topic.

Quick wins

  • Write a one-sentence scope statement before the first draft.
  • Use source evidence to support claims, not replace analysis.
  • End each section with a sentence that links back to the research question.

Turn EE Criteria Into A Stronger Draft

Upload your history EE draft to Marksy and get focused feedback on scope, evidence use, and the quality of your historical argument. The result includes a mark for every criterion, evidence from your draft, and the changes to make first.

  1. 1

    Upload your EE draft as a PDF

  2. 2

    Get a mark and feedback for every EE criterion

  3. 3

    Revise and grade the new version

A mark for every criterion
A mark for every criterionSee where the draft is now, criterion by criterion.
Comments on your sentences
Comments on your sentencesEach comment points at the passage it is about.
What to fix first
What to fix firstConcrete next edits instead of "improve your analysis".