How clearly you name the philosophical issue in the stimulus and justify why the stimulus raises it.
- Stronger evidence
- The issue is identified explicitly, with a clear justification of the link to the stimulus.
- Early-stage evidence
- The issue is implied rather than stated, and the link to the stimulus is not justified.
How well structured, focused, and clear the response is.
- Stronger evidence
- Well structured, focused, clear, and coherent.
- Early-stage evidence
- Poorly structured, or structured but barely focused on the task.
How accurate and relevant your philosophical knowledge is, how well you explain the issue, and how you use philosophical vocabulary.
- Stronger evidence
- Relevant, accurate, detailed knowledge, a well-developed explanation, and appropriate vocabulary throughout.
- Early-stage evidence
- Little relevant knowledge, a minimal explanation of the issue, and missing or misused philosophical vocabulary.
How developed your critical analysis is, how well examples support it, and how you handle counter-arguments.
- Stronger evidence
- Well-developed critical analysis, well-chosen examples, and counter-arguments analysed convincingly.
- Early-stage evidence
- Mostly descriptive, with little analysis and few or no examples.
How well you evaluate other interpretations, justify your points, and reach a consistent conclusion.
- Stronger evidence
- Clear evaluation of other views, nearly all points justified, a consistent position, and a clear conclusion that matches the argument.
- Early-stage evidence
- Little evaluation of other views, some main points justified, and no relevant conclusion.