Physics HL · Chapter 9: The Gas Laws
9.5 Real Gases and Model Limitations
Identify where ideal assumptions fail and use compressibility reasoning to judge model reliability.
Estimated time: 24 minutes
Where the Ideal Model Starts to Fail
Ideal-gas theory treats molecules as point particles with negligible mutual attraction except during collisions. At sufficiently high pressures, finite molecular size reduces available free volume. At sufficiently low temperatures, attractive intermolecular forces become dynamically important. Both effects shift measured -- behavior away from ideal predictions.
These deviations are not failures of physics but reminders that every model has a regime of validity. The ideal model is still enormously useful because it captures dominant behavior across a wide operating window, but precision work near condensation or very high compression requires correction terms.
Finite Molecular Volume and Intermolecular Forces
Finite volume means molecules cannot occupy all geometrically enclosed space equally. Attractive forces reduce wall-collision momentum transfer relative to ideal assumptions because molecules are partially pulled inward by neighbors before collision. Repulsive effects dominate at very short separation distances under strong compression.
In many treatments these effects appear as equation-of-state correction parameters. Even without full correction formulas, you should reason qualitatively: colder and denser states generally deviate more from ideal behavior than warmer, dilute states.
Compressibility Factor as a Deviation Signal
Ideal behavior corresponds to Z = 1. Deviations from 1 indicate non-ideal effects.
Compressibility factor gives a compact diagnostic. near indicates ideal approximation is likely acceptable. Systematic departures provide immediate evidence that molecular interactions and finite-size effects are no longer negligible. In practice, engineers and physicists use charts or more advanced state equations when high accuracy is needed.
For IB-style analysis, the key skill is judgment. Do the stated conditions suggest low-density moderate-temperature gas? If yes, use ideal equations confidently. If not, state that the ideal model gives first-order behavior but can over- or under-estimate measured quantities.
Simulation: Stress-Testing Ideal Conditions
Push the model toward high-pressure or low-temperature states and watch the built-in validity indicator warn about likely real-gas deviations.
Ideal Gas Law Lab
Active law interpretation
General mode lets n, V, and T vary freely so you can inspect full PV = nRT coupling.
Container micro-view (animated gas particles + piston)
P-V map with isotherms
State diagnostics
P
1745.9 kPa
17.23 atm
T
210.0 K
-63.1 deg C
V
3.50 L
3.5000e-3 m^3
Microscopic metrics
RMS speed c_rms: 345.0 m s^-1
Mean molecular kinetic energy: 4.349e-21 J
Density estimate: 44.000 kg m^-3
Monatomic internal energy estimate: 9166.2 J
Model validity note
Ideal-model caution: this state approaches regimes where intermolecular forces and finite molecular size become important.
Try this workflow: hold n fixed, then switch between Boyle/Charles/Gay-Lussac modes and verify each ratio form before returning to full-state PV = nRT checks.
Test Yourself
Which condition set is most likely to make a real gas behave approximately ideally?